Grocery shopping is a bugger even at the best of times (which is when the children aren’t with you, the trolley doesn’t wobble, you’ve remembered your list and your eco bags and raspberries are on special). But when you add a minor crisis of conscience at almost every step of the way, it becomes a TOTAL PAIN. We are faced with increasing numbers of ‘own brand’ (private supermarket branded) products, which we are oft told are hurting our farmers and our economy. Should I just gleefully grab the bargains or should I think more about provenance and integrity and long term gain?
It’s bloody tempting to reach past ‘premium’ branded sugar when supermarket private brands are about half the price. And sometimes it’s just impossible to find anything other than private brands (even if not ‘own’ branded, it’s often disguised – a la Macro health foods or Great Ocean Road cheeses, owned by Woolies and Coles respectively). Last week I left without cherry tomatoes because they were all Woolworth’s brand. But surely buying own brand is still supporting a tomato farmer somewhere?
Being married to a dairy farmer, I am most often asked about fresh milk. Specifically, (and very kindly) “which kind of milk can I buy that supports your business?” This question is asked more frequently since Coles dropped their pants and their milk prices to $1 per litre about 2 years ago, and Woolies followed suit. I always parrot off the same answer without knowing all the facts behind it, so I’ve done some homework and in doing so opened up a whole lot of new questions. This is a worm canny issue. Let’s milk it…
Is there a difference between own brand and home brand?
Well the major supermarket chains have their ‘own’ or ‘private’ brands, which are made up of three tiers – top end (Woolworth’s Select and Coles Finest), mid range (Woolworths or Coles brand) and the value tier (Coles Smartbuy or Woolie’s Home Brand). The top and mid tiered products are often dressed up to look eerily like the premium brands. There are also organic lines (such as Woolie’s Macro and Cole’s Organic).
Where are private brand products processed/produced?
There are no ginormous, Suess-esque Woollies or Coles factories chugging away day and night to produce every private brand product. It’s different for each product but some are made in the very same factories that make the premium brands, others are imported from overseas because it’s cheaper or there’s some kind of trade balance obligation with the particular country (don’t ask me about that, it’s another kettle of fish and I’m trying to focus on one issue at a time*).
Commonly the private brands – and the premium brands for that matter – are made up of ‘local and imported produce’ – you’ll see it on the label. There is usually no mention of percentages, which would indicate that the majority of the ingredients are cheaper imports.
Is there a quality difference between premium brands and private brands?
From what I can glean from the information at hand, the quality of many of the private brand products is negotiated between the retailer and the supplier (processor/producer) according to prices and recipes, quality etc. This means that in most cases, private branding does not equate with poorer quality.
When you get down to the value tier (Home Brand and Smart Buys), your chances of getting as good a product as the premium brands lessen (the jelly is shite, don’t go there).
Generally speaking, it’s reasonable to expect that you get what you pay for – i.e. the processor will likely downgrade the quality if they are being paid less for it. If the cost cut is absorbed by lower packaging costs, smaller net weights or other factors, then maybe the quality doesn’t suffer.
I sampled Coles Australian tinned diced tomatoes against Ardmona Australian tinned diced tomatoes (SPC owned, Coca-cola owned) and found that the recipe is slightly different in that Coles use tomato puree added to 60% tomatoes while Ardmona add juice. There is not much difference in taste but I would say Coles trumps Ardmona. Coles brand is 6c cheaper.
In other cases, such as with our milk (white or fresh milk), product standards are governed by Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) Food Standards Code. All full cream fresh milk, for instance, must contain at least 3.2% fat and 3.0% protein. The reduced fat varieties also have standards. This means that whether you buy home brand or Pura brand, you are getting the same product. In fact, in Tasmania, our milk gets picked up from our farm and transported to a factory that processes the lot and puts it into all private or Pura branded containers.
So great, in the case of milk, I’m getting the same product for a fraction of the price
Yes, but wait, there’s a catch (yes I am biased, but trust me, $1 per litre is actually too good to be true).
We as the farmers get paid considerably less for the percentage of milk that goes into private branded containers, but it costs us the same to get it out of the cows. We don’t have a Home Brand herd eating less nutritious grass, nor do we add water to the vat to make it go further – we can’t do that because of the FSANZ code. Nor can our processor (National Foods)add or subtract ingredients or take a step out of the processing procedure like other unregulated products (such as pasta or tinned fruit). For the first half of this year in fact, we were paid a price per litre that was under the cost of production and utterly unsustainable.
An unsustainable price to primary producers leads to farmers getting out of the industry altogether and a reduction in the amount of milk produced. And herewith comes the old shortage/surplus formula. If there is a shortage of milk (and there will be if we are forced too often to operate at a loss), hey presto – up, up, prices are up.
But didn’t the supermarkets say they’d absorb the costs of cutting milk prices?
Yes off course they did, they had to be seen to be doing the right thing by the little people. When Coles first cut the price of milk to $1 per litre, they gave the processor a negligible price rise which was never passed on to the farmers, essentially because it was negated by the fact that sale of more dollar litres caused a dramatic reduction in branded milk sales.
A Government inquiry into the effects of the price cut supported Cole’s claims that the dairy industry was not being negatively impacted by the price cuts, but these findings have been disputed ever since and there has been talk of the inquiry reopening. The Queensland Dairy Farmers Organisation estimates $220 million has been lost in 2 years since the price cuts were introduced.
Both supermarket giants have since (indirectly) admitted that the milk price cuts have impacted farmers. In March this year, Woolworths stated that the price drop, along with a high Aussie dollar and a tough export market is contributing to the struggle faced by farmers. This statement co-incided with the announcement that in parts of NSW, Woolworths would cut out the middle man and begin to source milk directly from the farm gate. Both giants are actively using farmers in marketing campaigns to convince the public that they are farmer-friendly. An admission of guilt if ever I’ve seen one.
Former executicve chairman of Woolworths, Paul Simons, noted recently that the milk price cuts have been the worst example of screwing the producer he has seen, that there is always a certain level of guilt involved in such cutthroat business dealings, but that the duopoly has no choice but to stay competitive.
Are the supermarkets making more money from milk since they dropped the price?
Not from milk sales, no. Last year, Coles sold 11% more milk but the value of sales was down by 2%. Woolies overall sales increased by 3.7% but sales decreased by 3%.
So why do they cut the price? Because milk is perishable and needs to be bought more regularly than the average family does the grocery shop. Previously most people popped into their local milk bar or service station for milk but now they go to the trouble of going into Coles or Woolies (and walking all the way down the back, past shelves and shelves of ‘bargains’ and temptations) to get their cheap milk. Cunning buggers these supermarkets aren’t they.
It’s no wonder we see so many empty corner shops these days. In Tasmania they are almost a thing of the past and if they do still exist, they have a sort of sad nostalgia about them.
Are people price motivated though, or would they rather support local industry?
Consumers, in general, are price conscious. We don’t want to believe it but the figures tell a story: over 72% of the total milk sold at Coles in 2011 was the $1 per litre own branded milk.
And the story is pretty much the same across all products – the public wants value for money. In fact in many cases, if suppliers chose to opt out of the private brand game, they would be losing around 70% of their business. Optimum shelf position as well as lower prices and copy-cat packaging has just made private brands a leader in so many product ranges.
But surely consumers can’t be blamed for being budget conscious?
No of course not. The cost of living is going up all the time, milk and fruit and vegetables are staples and I’m not about to sneer at anyone who wants to feed their children and keep the household budget down. But I would like to make sure they know that by all accounts (including our bank account), prices as outrageously low as $1 per litre price is unsustainable and the longer we support it the more farmers will be driven out of business and the more likely it is that local fresh produce will become a luxury product with a luxury price tag.
Is it better to buy an Australian private brand product or a premium brand import?
Australian all the way baby, preferably local. There are still local primary producers in work if demand is there. In many cases if the product isn’t taken to fill up home brand packaging, it isn’t taken at all. If consumer demand for imported products increases and local products stay on the shelf, Woolies and Coles will stop buying them. Factories or producers will be forced into bankruptcy, trees will have to be pulled out and farmers will walk off the land.
As it is, supermarkets and processors who have paid for their contracted local produce and then bought extra overseas produce will not hesitate to leave surplus local yields to rot in the ground or sour in the vat so as not to be overstocked. Understandable if the overseas bills are already paid – and a good season cannot be predicted – but the very fact that fresh local food is rotting while the same product is being imported tells me that the system is fucked. (I’ve been trying not to swear but I can’t think of a better word).
Frozen and tinned food industries are staring down the barrel of bum drop out already. They just can’t match the low prices of their overseas competitors. Right that’s it, it’s bloody cold in those freezery parts of the supermarket but I’m going to dig around until I find those Aussie frozen foods. Or not buy them at all.
Most of the tinned tomatoes (2 in 10 cans) we buy these days are Italian imports – they are cheaper for the supermarkets and cheaper for consumers, as well as making us all feel that our cooking is just that little bit more authentic (Italian tomatoes have a romance about them but there are allegations that workers in Italy are exploited for cheap labour).
You are very biased against the supermarkets, there must be a good reason to import products we can grow or manufacture here?
Well they are in business too and of course they will prioritise their bottom line over their consumers. They are facing increasing competition from overseas companies like Aldi and Costco who are a major discount players in the Australian grocery scene right now. These companies have limited ranges of unbelievably cheap own branded products which are creating a buzz. I understand that the supermarket duopoly must remain competitive. But for the 2012 financial year, Woolies made a $1.8 billion, while Coles profited just over $2 billion.
When I watch my husband working like a mule day after day for a dwindling profit (some years no profit at all), I find it hard to be sympathetic.
The sad fact of the matter is that if primary industry doesn’t play with the big boys, they don’t get to play at all. The supermarkets have the primary producers and the processors by the balls and they are squeezing just a little bit harder each year. This means that businesses must cut costs, play smarter, get bigger or get out. Many have already had to bail out, how many more years of this can the rest take? Howe long before we no longer have a choice but to buy private brands over whose ingredients and quality are determined by cost?
Here are my new shopping rules:
- Buy local (in my case, Tasmanian). If this means shopping at fruit markets, farmer’s markets, on farm then so be it.
- Buy Australian if there’s no Tassie/ local option. If there’s no Australian asparagus, don’t buy it. Asparagus makes your wee smell funny anyway.
- Buy premium if there is an Australian made/produced option.
- If really desperate, buy private brands if they are Australian produced over imported premium products.
- Don’t buy Italian olive oil and tinned tomatoes just because they look nice in the pantry and you might one day get all try hard magaziney and plant some herbs in the used tins.
- Don’t EVER be fooled into thinking the supermarkets are cutting prices for you – it’s never about the customer and always about margins.
The world’s population is over 7 billion and growing fast. And we all need to eat. I don’t think that food production is something we should be playing silly buggers with. Australian primary producers are precious and we need to look after them.
I would really like to see a campaign that counters the “down, down” catchcry with something that reflects consumers’ growing desire for provenance. Here’s my suggestion: “Great, great, farmers are great, shove the price cuts right up Cole’s date”. Or something.
Categories: Bonnet Bees, Opinions
Tags: coles, farmers, farmers under stress, farming, food, fresh food, fresh milk, fruit rotting on trees, home brand, imported produce, italian tomatoes, overpopulation, own brands, primary producers, private brands, pura milk, supermarket brands, supermarket duopoly, supermarkets, tinned tomatoes, white milk, woolies, woolworths
Thanks for your post. I often feel like everything I pick up I have to put back for one reason or another. Reading labels is a miserable task and shopping takes me at least 30mins longer than it did when I didn’t have a conscience. I have just started reading Wheat Belly and my god, I am in another world of pain trying to avoid wheat. I have to say, I feel completely different in only 5 days and although I don’t have an intolerance or allergy, it is obviously affecting me ways I never associated with. Damn it! I love pasta and bread, not sure how long I’ll survive (happily) without it but education is wisdom. My kids might just have to get used to rice noodles from now on. Unless, is there something I should know about rice??! lol
I love planting my herbs in cans! Oh no, I am a try hard! Another interesting post Meg.
You’re not a try hard Bec because you actually are one of the magazine people – if not literally then in my head. Style guru comes to mind…x
Yep Mo it seems as though everything’s bad for us or bad for something. You have me thinking about wheat – I am a total wheat addict and while I think I can’t live without it maybe I should give it a go….one day.
Meg, can I please clarify the tinned tomato issue!!! The Ardmona brand is 97% AUSTRALIAN tomato…havent ever seen a Coles brand tin, but even if theirs are Australian, at only 60%, fruit, the Ardmona is the better buy?
Hi Carol, my Ardmona tin didn’t specify their Australian content, just had Australian written all over it and even had a picture of the tomato farmer and his boy. I took this to mean it was 100% Australian. The Coles brand didn’t specify either…is the non-transparency part of the problem? But as per my new shopping rules, I will be buying Ardmona over Coles or Woolies.
Accurate and disturbing writing. I try to avoid in-house brands for the reasons stated. Some in-house products may be acceptable if there’s just one ingredient. They can’t dilute sugar, and it comes from the same places as CSR or the like. We rely so much on our farmers, and only when they are gone will we realise that we have made a short-term savings at the expense of he long term. I have shares in supermarkets, and do *not* like the direction they are taking.
Note the use of the word “sustainable”. This word and others like it once used mainly in conservation-related matters are now common in finance and consumer matters. It will get worse. See Catalyst http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/3796205.htm about extreme weather.
Thanks Meg for demystifying the milk thing in particular! Having worked for a food manufacturer once years ago, its no news to me that the big supermarket chains are not the good guys, and smaller producers engaging with them don’t usually end well. They really do put on the squeeze. And bugger me, I had not realised that Great Ocean Road was a supermarket-owned brand either.
Buying food has become so much more convoluted over the last few decades, with legs everywhere; I mean it suits our economy in so many ways for people to put food somewhere down low on the priority list and just choose the cheapest and easiest options.
I can completely relate to the aggravation that comes with having to study and decipher labelling, and even if you get informed, there seems to be an ever evolving practice of creative ways to meet labelling guidelines, like New Zealand-labelled products being quite able to be Chinese origin.
Anyway I’m with you, if a country ever stops being able to feed itself, there’ll be hell to pay. So, Australian all the way.
Love love love your blogs. We now only buy ashgrove milk which we see as local and excellent and our local, Salamanca Fruit Market now stocks heapsvof it. I now realise your milk is Pura. Poop. I wasn’t sure what was in Pura. Obvious really. Just wanted to say that i love the research and delivery! Twins 5mths, asleep, (not mine but stolen 🙂 Nigella’s gingerbread cake in the oven….
Sent from my iPad
Thank you Mary! Ah there’s nothing quite as lovely as sleeping twins. Except maybe gingerbread.
Glad you are buying Australian tomatoes. So many recipes specify Italian tomatoes. Why? I have tasted both and taste no discernible difference.
Hi Meg –
Great post – really does spell out what we probably all knew, but didn’t quite want to admit, because knowing all of this makes shopping even harder, as you point out. But your “list” of what to buy works will certainly help!
I’d like to add another thing we can all do to ensure food security and sustainability: grow our own. While we can’t all feed our families completely from our backyards (particularly if we live in inner-city areas), we can do a lot to eat seasonally, without chemicals and pesiticides coating our food, by growing our own. And seeds are cheap, so helpful on the family budget!
And for those living inner-city in apartments, you too can grow your own: Indira Naidoo, the fabulous journalist who used to anchor the ABC News, has produced a marvellous book titled The Edible Blacony, published by Penguin Books.
Thanks Kate – this is a point I did miss. A great one. We all need a veggie patch, a water tank – and maybe a few goats to milk.
I’m happy to buy Australian canned products if they’re up to scratch. However, I read the labels very carefully as many many Australian products contain large amounts of added sugar whereas the overseas produced equivalent doesn’t. For example chick peas, cannellini and other beans, whole and diced tomatoes. I am NOT going to pay more for a product that is less healthy.
Good point Lynn, I will check sugar contents too. Thanks.
Seriously interesting article – thanks for doing the research and giving us the answers to what has been a mind-meltdown in the supermarket!
My pleasure Elissa. So glad I’m not the only one whose brain fades out on entry to the supermarket.
Thanks for that Meg. I must admit that with the confusing labeling of products it is very hard to know where products come from. But we refrain from the cheap milk knowing, as I do, how hard it is for farmers to make a crust. Tough life you have chosen.
That’s great Richard thank you – I wish more people thought that way.
And is it just me, here in rural Queensland, noticing that there is more and more ‘own brand’ appearing on the shelves, and less and less of any other choice?
No it’s not just you Finella. You’re right. They are creating more ‘brands’ within their own brands – even more since I wrote this article. And the other brands they do include are pushed to the very bottom or top of shelves. Takes me ages to get around the supermarket these days.
Really enjoyed reading this Meg, thank you. Something struck me when I read the comment about playing with the big boys, or not getting to play at all – I would love to see more direct sales from the farm to consumer, or even processor to consumer (given the impracticalities of both growing and processing some products like you have with milk). I think it’s possibly a tricky solution in the short term but certainly possible and way more sustainable long term – for a bit of a model description check out Joel Salatin and the “polyface farm” story (google them, you tube them or read one of Joel’s many books – i just read ‘fields of farmers’ = awesomeness and wisdom for consumers and farmers alike on every page!). Cheers
Brilliant I will certainly look at what Joel is doing, thank you. Yes it’s a minefield of hurdles when it comes to selling fresh milk direct and one we are tentatively investigating, I look forward to Joels insights.
Great write up Meg but you missed one very important fact about the dairy / milk industry crisis . From what has been written by a local dairy farmer here in Qld the big boys are hell bent on doing away with “fresh milk” and are pushing an agenda to just stock UHT milk as they do not have to worry about stock loss also no refrigeration needed and as usual they WILL import it from a cheaper source overseas . Apparently in Qld so many dairy farmers have shut down becasue of the $1 milk and because of the shortfall the big boys and the processors are bring it from interstate .
Hi Howard, yes I had heard of this possibility but thought it was a while away – looks like it could come sooner rather than later. It’s one of the arguments I use when people ask me why should they buy the more expensive brands – “because farmers will go out of business and all that will be left is powdered or UHT milk”. It’s truly disturbing. Thanks for the insight. Do you have a link to the article?
The guy who put up the article is a local dairy farmer here in South East Qld Scenic Rim 4 Real Robotic Dairy http://www.scenicrim4realmilk.com.au/ he keeps a blog going on their Facebook Page as well . He is the one who posted your article .
Hate to add to your supermarket dilemmas and worm canny issues but animal welfare is also a biggie for us. We try to get “happy animal” products but the labelling here is again misleading and sometimes downright confusing (barn laid vs free range vs barn range?? wtf). So we try to avoid buying animal products from the supermarkets nowadays, we either catch our own (from the ocean), lay our own (well our chooks do) or buy directly from the primary producer where we know the animals have been treated humanely.
Between the fabulous bream creek farmers market (www.breamcreekfarmersmarket.com.au – shameless plug), our vegie patch, the local co-op and the local farmers selling us half a side of cow/sheep/goat every now and again we can pretty much buypass (excuse the pun) the supermarkets – Hooray.
“We don’t have a Home Brand herd eating less nutritious grass” – love it 🙂
Yep it’s certainly very confusing. Coles now sells “RSPCA Approved” chickens. You are doing brilliantly to make the efforts you are. But it shouldn’t be such an effort, too few people can be bothered, hence the success of the bastard supermarkets. Thanks Dougal.
Totally agree….I have been helping our local dairy farm/cheesery for the past three years, making and selling cheese at Farmers Markets. They started in response to the drought when they needed to value add as their herd was cut from 190 milkers to 35 due to lack of feed . We try and buy our weekly needs at these markets and top up with locally sourced products from smaller supermarkets like the IGA in our small local town. Small efforts from us but if everyone did the same, more farmers could feel comfortable going ahead into the future .
Keep up the great work Paul – thank you.